Why We’re Sad for Justin Baldoni (And It’s Okay)

If you’ve found yourself sighing into your matcha latte or texting your best friend “UGH” in all caps this week, you’re not alone. The news just hit: the court dismissed Justin Baldoni’s $400 million defamation lawsuit against Blake Lively.

And sure, maybe you’re not legally involved—but emotionally? You were invested.

We’re here to say: it’s totally okay to be sad about it. When a man like Justin—who’s practically the human embodiment of a warm blanket and an emotionally available boyfriend—gets shut down like that, it feels personal.

So what now? We self-soothe, of course. With TV. With feelings. With snacks. And a whole lot of Baldoni energy.

What Happened With Justin Baldoni’s Lawsuit?

ICYMI: Justin Baldoni filed a massive $400 million lawsuit claiming defamation related to comments allegedly made by actress Blake Lively. The details? Messy. The result? The case was dismissed.

While the legal back-and-forth may be over, what remains is the collective ache of fans who adore Baldoni for his vulnerability, his advocacy, and his unapologetic softness in a world that often rewards the opposite.

No, we don’t know all the facts. But we know our hearts hurt. So now? We watch.

Why We Love Justin Baldoni—On Screen and Off

Justin isn’t just a handsome face with a perfect beard and sad-boy eyes. He’s the creator of Man Enough, a podcast and book project redefining masculinity. He’s a feminist. A dad. A rom-com king. And a walking permission slip to feel your feelings.

On Jane the Virgin, he turned what could’ve been a cliché into a layered, lovable, golden-hearted role. Off screen, he’s told men that crying is strong, not shameful. That loving deeply is brave, not weak.

He’s one of the good ones. And even if the courts didn’t rule in his favor, our hearts still do.

TV Therapy: Justin Baldoni Shows to Watch and Feel Better

Let’s be honest: sometimes you need to binge-watch your way through disappointment. If you're feeling a little let down on behalf of our emotional support celebrity, try one (or all) of these:

Jane the Virgin

An absolute gem. Justin plays Rafael, a reformed rich boy with feelings, depth, and a truly chaotic love life. It’s soapy, sweet, and surprisingly soul-stirring.

Clouds

Based on a true story, this film (which Baldoni directed) will make you ugly cry in the best way. Catharsis in cinematic form.

Man Enough (Podcast + Book)

Not a show, but a vibe. Listen while walking your dog or lying on the floor wondering why life isn’t fair.

Five Feet Apart

Produced by Baldoni, this teen romance packs a punch. Bring tissues. And chocolate.

No, we are not recommending THAT movie in this space.

Still Sad? Watch These Shows That Feel Like a Justin Hug

If you’ve watched every Baldoni project and still feel like you need emotional Neosporin, these shows might help:

• Heartstopper – Wholesome queer love and soft boys with good boundaries? Sign us up.

• The Bold Type – Friendship, feminism, and fantastic fashion. Plus, strong men who listen.

• This Is Us – Emotional whiplash but make it beautiful.

• Love, Victor – Awkward, adorable, and deeply relatable.

These series won’t erase the injustice, but they will wrap you in storylines that restore your faith in good guys with open hearts.

What We Can Learn: Feeling Things Is Still Cool

In a world obsessed with hot takes, courtroom wins, and “clapping back,” Justin reminds us that being kind is revolutionary. That softness is strength. That emotional depth isn’t a flaw—it’s the whole point.

So if you're feeling low about this lawsuit, let that feeling be. Watch something healing. Journal about it. Hug your dog. Text your emotionally intelligent friend.

And know you’re not alone.

Final Thoughts: We’re Still Rooting for You, Justin

Justin Baldoni may have lost in court, but he’s still winning where it counts—in hearts, minds, and TV marathons everywhere.

To every woman who cried during Jane the Virgin and got a little too emotionally involved in this lawsuit drama: you’re seen, you’re valid, and yes—you should absolutely rewatch Season 3 tonight.

Justin, if you’re reading this: call us. Or just keep being your emotionally evolved self. We’ll be over here, rooting for you (with popcorn).